LoginRegister Search
Subject: Most reliable Expedition Vehicle

You are not authorized to post a reply.   
Page 4 of 7 << < 1234567 > >>
AuthorMessages
Craig Miller
Title Sponsor


02/10/2009 3:20 PM Alert 

Ike,

I love the JKs, *but* as an Expedition Rig the MPG makes them a poor choice. As you know, I'm planning to take a trip into the very remote bush of Canada next summer. 400 miles between fuel stops. I hope to do similar trips in other parts of the world in my future. I spoke with a well known company that builds aftermarket Jeeps and invited them on the Canada trip. Even they thought the JK was a poor choice for that sort of trip. I want to buy a vehicle that can be my Expedition rig for many many years. Something that I can build up to be able to take me on long trips, short trips, trail runs, and anything else I can dream up.

I love the JKs, and have been considering them hard for a while now. If they put a fuel efficient diesel in one I'd definitely consider one (Note the Rubicon Unlimited was on my original list).

 

Oh, and they are out of my budget right now.


My Overland Adventure Blog
Brian Rutherford



02/10/2009 5:14 PM Alert 

As part of the equation, ask yourself how much time do you want to spend in your carport, as compared to spending that same time on the road? Builing a vehicle, (not just adding a few aftermarket goodies) can consume great amounts of time.

Yes, an older vehicle built piece by piece, by you, is known to you so can be repaired by you, if you have a spare part with you. A new vehicle with electronics might be a mystery to you, until you repair a part that failed.  I have found I get to know a vehicle part by part as they "ask" for help. I agree with an earlier post that you might not want to give up all the "electronics", as they can help give better MPG, and sometimes better reliability too. With a Scangauge, and a good manual, and some common sense, most road "failures" are really parts swaps, not parts rebuilding. Guessing which parts to bring is pretty much the same game with or without electronics.

Brian


http://www.pbase.com/railvan
Benny Benson



02/10/2009 6:36 PM Alert 
If you get a chance there is a write up in the April issue of Petersen's 4wheel&offrad about a Volvo Roamer. It looks very well set up.

Chuck Norris doesn't always drink beer, but when he does, he has the Dos Equis guy serve it to him in a dress!
Dave King



02/10/2009 7:13 PM Alert 

I know I'm late to the discussion but...

Most reliable overland Vehicle. Pretty easy, 70 Series Landcruiser. Nothing on the planet has this kind of capability combined with this type of reliability. It's no hype, I've wheeled them in Australia and they really are the cream of teh crop world wide. The only thing that comes close is a G-Wagen.

I know there are alot of Rover guy's here and I really love Rovers, but, well... they're just not that reliable when compared to the Big T. Toyota is the benchmark by wich all others are measured.

Cheers

Dave

 

Edit: if this is specific to N.America then the answer is either a Tacoma or an older Toyota Mini-truck or a 60-Series Cruiser.  If you want big/camper-esque tehn either a Volvo C303/TGB1111 or a Mog is what you want, but in terms of an every-day vehicle that is easy to find parts for then again you simply cannot beat a Toyota of some sorts.  My current rig has over 240K on teh clock adn the ony thing that rattles is the stuff I carry in it and the driver hahahahaha.  Yep, I'm that guy... I LOVE Toyotas.


Project 4Rescue: 1st Gen 1989 Toyota 4Runner aka"The Super Turtle"
22RE, 5spd, Marlin Rear Bumper, OME Dakar / BJ spacers, 31x10.50's 4.10's, Soon to be 33x10.50 and 4.88's

Toyota: Apparently our humor is misunderstood
Benny Benson



02/10/2009 7:50 PM Alert 
I was going to recommend the earthroamer jeep platform but then checked their website....WOW!
http://www.earthroamer.com/tab_xpedition_vehicles/xvjp6_pricing.html

Chuck Norris doesn't always drink beer, but when he does, he has the Dos Equis guy serve it to him in a dress!
Dave King



02/10/2009 8:52 PM Alert 
yeah those XV-JP's are quite cool eh. But very very expensive (although not for what you get and teh build quality I'm told) I really want to do something simmilar with my 1st Gen 4Runner (Hillux Surf to you folks down under) The removable top really give it so much potential but I don't know that the 22RE is going to be up to hauing some camper thingy on it's back eh ; )

Chers

Dave

Project 4Rescue: 1st Gen 1989 Toyota 4Runner aka"The Super Turtle"
22RE, 5spd, Marlin Rear Bumper, OME Dakar / BJ spacers, 31x10.50's 4.10's, Soon to be 33x10.50 and 4.88's

Toyota: Apparently our humor is misunderstood
Isaac Fain



02/11/2009 7:49 AM Alert 
"Even they thought the JK was a poor choice for that sort of trip. "

Ummm ... i have to say they are speaking foolishness, then. if that's the case, why is Earthroamer building JK's now?

All these super-duper dream-type diesel vehicles you guys dream of don't get THAT GREAT of gas mileage. An old, bare-bones simple diesel isn't going to be that much more fuel efficient than a modern gasoline engine. A new computer managed diesel is big money.

Case in point - I held the gas pedal down for 3,000 miles, towing a U-haul, with the entire family loaded up in moving from Seattle to NYC. Going up the continental divide, keeping RPM's at 4~5k RPM all the way up I still got 13~15 MPG. Doing as close to 80mph as it would go, for as long as I cared to rev it in 3rd and 4th gear. The rest of the trip was between 14~20 depending on hills and headwind. And you know me ... I was driving it pretty hard. We made somewhere around 800 miles in one of those days.

On that cross-country trip, my range with the factory gastank was between 350~424 or so, with the hammer down. Once you add an 18 gallon, BOLT-IN tank from those crazy aussie guys at Longranger you easily are looking at 600 mile range with the gasser V6 and adverse conditions. Not to mention whatever reserve can be carried in good ol' jerry cans. Whatever the amount is to pay and have it shipped here is going to be far less than a finicky conversion project to a diesel. Certainly not the cost of just ancillaries to make it work in whatever truck you end up with.

I cannot argue with the bloody expensive part. Certainly with a new vehicle of any kind it's a "bought not built" reality. If you watch for 2007 model X's they are starting to come down as the economy goes sour and people are trying to get out of their payments.

check out the link - it'll be one of my first mods:

http://www.thelongranger.com.au/jklongrangefueltank.html





crashed '97 Discovery I - "Calypso"
Craig Miller
Title Sponsor


02/11/2009 8:05 AM Alert 
A TDI Defender gets 25-40% better fuel economy. If it isn't leaky, it can be submersed under water with a snorkel and not die a violent death, and can run bio-diesel for substantially less CO2 output. For the type of expedition I'm talking about, the one we IMd about, both of the two former points are important to me. The latter isn't an expedition requirement but is attractive to me personally.

Adding a tank to carry extra fuel just means I have that much less room under the max payload to carry HoHos and Juicy pouches. I'd rather start with a higher mpg than pull a trailer full of fuel.


My Overland Adventure Blog
Isaac Fain



02/11/2009 8:15 AM Alert 
i can't touch the HoHo's and juicy pouches. cased closed

crashed '97 Discovery I - "Calypso"
Ryan Hall



02/11/2009 8:35 AM Alert 

This really is a great thread.  The diversity is amazing. Craig, what ever choice you make I,m sure after looking at your truck, it will be an amazing ride that will take you into areas not yet explored by present day explorers. GOod luck in yuor quest for the ultimate rig.

Ryan


Ryan
Craig Miller
Title Sponsor


02/11/2009 8:47 AM Alert 

If AEV puts a simple diesel in one of these, and I had the money, I'd be all over it.  I love this concept.  It reminds me of the X-panda RTT that I want to put on a 100" Defender.

Who am I kidding.  Unless it is a custom 100" TDI Defender I'm never going to be happy.  I've clearly already made up my mind, it just took this thread to convince me I wasn't completely crazy.  Anwya, some pics of the Jeep, the X-panda, and the truck I really want.













My Overland Adventure Blog
Ed Sanman



02/11/2009 9:23 AM Alert 
Craig - I've been sitting back watching this thread, and felt all along this was where you'd end up. I like your choice, and would sure like to do the same to my 90, but can't justify it now. That looks like Craig Reese's truck that Rover Hybrids started probably 7 years ago. I was with Craig and Shane on that truck's last trip before the work was to begin. Remembering their rationalization for the project back then, you and they have a lot in common. They were certainly way ahead of the curve back then. And Shane's skills and attention to detail is exceptional.
I like where they're going with that roof modification. By the way, have you seen Jim Clark's 300TDI 110 with the new Dormobile roof? Those are available again, and modifying a 110 should cost less than building a D100.
Nevak Risew



02/11/2009 9:25 AM Alert 
Craig-

You may want to contact Gord'n. PM on the way
Craig Miller
Title Sponsor


02/11/2009 9:29 AM Alert 
I haven't seen Jim's truck. I'll check the PCRC website to see if he's posted any pics. The reason the 90s and 110s are even on my list is because they are likely to be cheaper and simpler to build. Though, I'll probably do what I planned all along and start with an RRC, put in the diesel, add lockers, tires, etc then down the road when I have the money see if Gordon can do a body swap.

Still, an imported 110 is probably a lot simpler and cheaper in the long run. If only I had an infinite amount of cash on hand.

C

My Overland Adventure Blog
Ed Sanman



02/11/2009 9:34 AM Alert 
I'll get in touch with Jim and see if he's planning on bringing it up to the PCRC Chehalis annual meeting and car show. Jim lives here in the Portland area. I heard you'll be there as a vendor, correct?
Ed Sanman



02/11/2009 9:46 AM Alert 

I went to Rover Hybrid's web site and there's a page devoted to the D100 build-up.  I was wrong about the donor vehicle.  I thought they were going to use his D90, but see they actually built the D100 starting with a SIII 88".   http://www.roverhybrids.com/D100_build_up.html

Craig Miller
Title Sponsor


02/11/2009 9:51 AM Alert 
Yeah, I've spoken with Shane at length. It was my plan when I started trying to sell the DII about a year ago. Not sure if/when this will ever happen. I think the first step is to get out of the DII and into an RRC/D1 that I can still use as a daily drive.

Craig

My Overland Adventure Blog
Nevak Risew



02/11/2009 10:37 AM Alert 
It would be hard to do better than a coil sprung 100" Tdi Series or Defender. Great choice all around.
Dale Avery



02/11/2009 11:43 AM Alert 

All this talk about bio-diesels is great.  BUT, if you are serious about doing the backcountry in Canada, you'll discover that there aren't a lot of McDonalds out there where you can pick up that used, filtered cooking oil.  I think that Expeditions West Crewcab Tacoma pulling the Adventure trailer (or whatever brand it is) looks like the way I'd go.  Parts for it everywhere in the world.  If you have the service manual/parts number, you can walk into any Toyota dealer anywhere and they can get you the part.

Neither of my Rovres ever left me in the dirt, but I was always a bit uneasy about having something break far from home.  There aren't too many Rover dealers near Fishtail, MT.  Where's Fishtail, you say?  Easy.  If you draw a triangle based on the towns of Absarokee in the north, Roscoe to the southeat, and Nye to the southwest, You'll find Fishtail right in the middle! 

p.s. If I had the money, I'd love to make you an offer on that DII of yours, Craig.  Very nicely setup rig!

 


After 35+ years running on four wheels, I've gone to the dark side and am playing on two.
2002 BMW F650GS Dakar dualsport
2006 BMW R1150RT sport touring bike
Craig Miller
Title Sponsor


02/11/2009 12:09 PM Alert 

Dale,

I'm very serious about doing back country travel in Canada, as well as south/central America, Alaska, and hopefully one day other parts of the world like Mongolia (cheers Dan).  I'm not looking for Straight Vegetable Oil, I'm looking at bio-diesel. By simply replacing a couple of hoses you can run bio-diesel or plain diesel in any diesel engine.

I just did a quick google search and the closest Toyota Dealer to Canol, NWT is 1,154 miles away.  I'm starting to think that a dog sled team or a mule is the only real way to go. 

The one thing I might do different than the 100" Defender in the photo above is to put a Mercedes 617 diesel in, instead of a Rover TDI.  The Mercedes 617 is probably the most reliable small diesel in the world.  Dual timing chains, and could probably burn peanut butter in a pinch.

Craig


My Overland Adventure Blog
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Page 4 of 7 << < 1234567 > >>

Forums > Vehicles > Tech > Most reliable Expedition Vehicle



ActiveForums 3.6
Copyright (C) 2010 Northwest Overland Society, LLC   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement