LoginRegister Search
Subject: To fridge or not to fridge

You are not authorized to post a reply.   
Page 1 of 3123 > >>
AuthorMessages
TooRisky



03/30/2009 12:11 AM Alert 

This is crazy, why am I always on the oppiste side of the spectrum with everybody....Screw that over price refridge, jeez save hundereds of dollars and go to a truckstop and buy a refridge....$200.00 will buy you the top of the line and size....They also have replacement parts for the long term commitment....Who are you gonna trust for dependability, a over the road trucker on a  limeted budget, or a salesman who does not, has not, and probably will not ever eat out of his ARB refridge for an extendended amount of time......With ARB you are paying so much more for a damn name, to what...keep you food cool on a camping trip, well truckers are always on that camping trip, and you wont find ARB in there rigs.....

Steve

Craig Miller
Title Sponsor


03/30/2009 12:36 AM Alert 

Got a link Steven?  Tell us more about what type of refridgeration unit the truck fridges use, how they do on steep angles, bouncing down a trail, and overall power consumption.  Are they proven offroad wordwide like the Engel/ARB (I know... the new ARB is not an Engel)?

What salesman are you talking about?  Brent/Scott at Columbia Rovers are hardly *salesman*.  They are our friends, fellow offroaders, and are offering us a steep discount on the new ARB fridge just for signing up on the website.  Similarly, everyone I've ever met at ARB is passionate about offroading and offroading tech.  Seth, who is responsible for ARBs North American Sales now, and Chris who was in charge in the past are both significantly more accomplished offroaders and fabricators than 99% of the people on NW Overland Society.

 Pictures from NWOS trips below:  Seth, Brent, and Scott (changing my tire).  Scott was voted by NWOS members as "Member of the Year" in 2007.













My Overland Adventure Blog
Craig Miller
Title Sponsor


03/30/2009 8:02 AM Alert 

Chris demonstrating how to winch a truck backwards, using a winch mounted on the front during a driver training class in 2007.







My Overland Adventure Blog
Joe Koegler



03/30/2009 8:44 AM Alert 

Steve,

Yes the prices are insane when compared to cooler or even full size household fridges. And yes I'm biased -- I have a Norcold 60L and a ARB 45L both bought used in the sub $400 range.

But there is a reason why they are so expensive and why people are willing to pay the premium. Check RV/marine stores/sites/forums and you will find mostly two brands: Norcold and Dometic (Norcold portables are another branding variation of the Engel/ARB lines). These are almost always compressor based true fridge/freezers and are very electrically efficient. They use an expensive "swing motor", have thermostats and variable temp control, often incorporate intelligent circuitry for battery monitoring with low voltage cutouts etc. These can run for days off a primary battery and still leave you enough starting power.

I'd guess that  what you are thinking of in the $200 range are most likely electrically-inefficient 12V  "coolers". They cannot actually get to freezing temps due to the technology. These jobbies use a thermocouple (or Peltier) device-based cooler. They will only cool to a certain temp. below ambient (and conversely above ambient as a food warmer when polarity is reversed), run pretty much constantly and drain your battery within 24 hours. Or at least the Igloo "fridge" I bought did. These are fine in a semi that runs constantly for long periods of time and has a big 12V reserve.

I would argue to go with an ARB/Engel/Norcold fridge/freezer or stick with ice and cooler and leave the 12V coolers alone.

 


"Flying is learning how to throw yourself at the ground and miss." - Douglas Adams
Andy Berglund



03/30/2009 10:57 AM Alert 
Also, don't most semis spend much of their time idling or on shore power when at a stop? With something like an Engel, et al, they can be used off the onboard power of a much smaller vehicle. I bet that a semi uses multiple 4D batteries or larger-their RC is much greater than even an Odyssey 2250.

Anyhow, it seems like the guys have hit all the other high points about the benefits of the right tool for the right job here. The Engel has been proven, period. It is expensive, no question. Once you have one thought it seems to become more important than some family members.

Regarding the fab-skillz of the ARB "salesmen" that Liberty that Craig posted has had a straight axle swap front, four linked in the rear and a very low overall ride height. Anyhow, I think when it comes to you being on the opposite spectrum as everyone else, I think that it comes down to personal preference. I personally don't have an Engel. I use Scott's I would get one but I'm cheap and I agree with you that they are way expensive. Not overpriced, per se, for the engineering, but expensive. I think it would be safe to say that the camping trips that over the road truckers are on is different from the trips we like taking, too.

Different strokes for different folks is what makes this place cool.

Andy

I am loving the Gilmore Girls-Scott Williams
Jay Erickson
Member Sponsor


03/30/2009 11:20 AM Alert 

A decade or so ago I bought one of those peltier based coolers thinking it would save food in our fridge if we ever lost power by using a deep cycle batt, that sucker drained the battery so fast and never got that cool that I just put it in storage and haven't drug it out since. Went back to using ice/dry ice whenever I needed to keep stuff cool.

*edit - I think it's great we're being offered such a deal on them but the expense & size are a drawback for me at this time.  I could definitely see this mounted in one of those little combat trailers some of you pull around. 


Traded in all my project vehicles for my 2009 Xterra, not an ounce of buyers remorse.
Craig Miller
Title Sponsor


03/30/2009 11:38 AM Alert 

I didn't consider a fridge as necessary until I started planning for a 10 day trip in the hot sun without any stops back in civilization for ice. Sure, I could have eaten canned/dehydrated backpacking food for the latter 7 days but fresh milk, eggs, produce, meats, and cheeses are better.

The fridge cost less than either of my bumpers, winch, and many other components that will be gone as soon as I sell the truck. Given the known reliability of the fridge, I expect to have it in whatever truck I own for decades.  The amortized cost is therefore quite low when compared to most of the other mods I've done to my truck.


My Overland Adventure Blog
Andy Berglund



03/30/2009 11:49 AM Alert 
Jay-

I agree with you but it's mainly so that I don't drive myself crazy with another "must have" item. I don't know about you but I always bring a good sized cooler on longer trips. The Engel is about the same size and so much more practical. No small pond at the bottom at the end of the trip, everything stays dry and cool. So cool. But in lieu of getting one now I recommend making good friends with someone who has one. Do you have any special skills to offer in trade? I've found that that helps.

I am loving the Gilmore Girls-Scott Williams
Jay Erickson
Member Sponsor


03/30/2009 3:56 PM Alert 
Hehe, I'm still in the mindset of carrying too much processed food and making regular stops back in civilization. My ideal trip is pretty much just a couple days off the beaten path, resupply and move on to the next out of the way spot. I'm sure I'll modify my thinking after a couple trips this spring/summer as I hopefully meet up with some of you.

Traded in all my project vehicles for my 2009 Xterra, not an ounce of buyers remorse.
Isaac Fain



03/30/2009 4:52 PM Alert 
kipper snacks go great with red wine. just sayin'.

crashed '97 Discovery I - "Calypso"
TooRisky



03/31/2009 10:11 PM Alert 

Hmmm funny, when was the last time you needed to keep a piece of meat frozen for 10 days, a beer or anything cold for 10 days.....When was the last time you were ever away from any sort of civility for 10 days.....5 days......Yes there are some that go to Everast, to the moon for that matter, that the top of the line, most expensive things are need to stay alive....Is this you, ask that question. Are you going into the Amazon,  the Artic circle, Afganistan for any length of time and need a cooler to get you though....99% will have to answer no....who is to go on a 2 week trip where you will never see another, much less some sort of store in their travels.....

The argument is viable, only if the situation calls for it....This is my point.

Why spend all that money for something that I agree will work wonders, but your travels are maybe a weekend, or a week with in reach of a store if needed....

Its just how you look at it....Do you really need an over price RR to get into the woods and enjoy...The same goes for a cooler, do you really need an $800.00 ARB cooler to keep a couple cokes cool for a couple days....

Just me...Not stepping on toes but possibly opening minds and saving money in these tough times....

Steve

Mike Rupp
Member Sponsor


03/31/2009 10:23 PM Alert 
Steven, I understand that you don't see the value in an $800 fridge. I do, though, and a bunch of people do as well. I hate coolers. I hate soggy stuff in a cooler. I hate emptying the water out of a cooler. I hate buying ice. I hate the sound of ice sloshing around as I drive. I truly hate everything about them.

If I were completely starting from scratch all over again, the absolute first thing I'd purchase for my truck would be an ARB fridge.

If you like coolers, more power to you. But do we really need to get into a discussion about what is needed? Do we really need to go offroading or camping? This is all a luxury and as such I treat it so. It isn't about what is needed, but what is desired.

WZ7V

Study for amateur radio exams here


Andy Berglund



03/31/2009 10:24 PM Alert 
Posted By Steven Schauer on 03/31/2009 10:11 PM

.....Yes there are some that go to Everast, to the moon for that matter, that the top of the line, most expensive things are need to stay alive....Is this you, ask that question.

...

Its just how you look at it....Do you really need an over price RR to get into the woods and enjoy..

 

Steve


I think you're getting it.  We have found that we are those people.    We like to bring civility with us.  Rather, I like having it around; I can't speak for anyone else directly.  If I wanted nature "unplugged" as it were, I would still be backpacking.  I love backpacking.  I just love this type of travel more.  I don't think that just because I'm on the trail I ought to eat Hamburger Helper.  I have much love for the simple hotdog cooked over the fire but I really like the challenge of making something delicious in the middle of nowhere.

As for the RR (which I assume to be Range Rover) you clearly haven't shopped around.  I've ridden bicycles more expensive than what a decent stock Rangie goes for.  Anyhow, either you get it or you don't.  You don't *need* 99% of the stuff we get.  But as you said the goal is to "get into the woods and enjoy" and part of that enjoyment for most of us is the gadgetry. 

Anyhow, not having your food swimming in a pool of their own juices at the bottom of an ice chest is reason enough for most people.

Andy


I am loving the Gilmore Girls-Scott Williams
Mike Rupp
Member Sponsor


03/31/2009 10:28 PM Alert 
Steven, what is your opinion on $40 titanium coffee mugs?

WZ7V

Study for amateur radio exams here


TooRisky



03/31/2009 11:43 PM Alert 

Well it is plain and simple.....a $40.00 cup is the same as a tin can I find abandoned on the side of the road, they both hold liquid, and will quench my thirst at a cool river....I have found we are different people of the same skin, is it right, wrong, no...it is indifferent. I guess I ride different than some and it is not bad, or good...just different.....we share a common goal of exploring, searching a place we have not been before, or re-exploring for what we missed the first time around....The difference is what we take on this journy, will it matter the out come like Lewis and Clark....probably not.....It is the comfort of the travel now, thats the question we have at hand....lets agree to disagree, I doubt life depends on the choice of what keeps our food cool...none of us are on our way to the moon, everestt or any other far off place alien to life as we know it....I dont know how ice came into this mix, I was never talking about an ice chest, so I was mistaken at that level of a sunday BBQ.

I will never point at yout ARB fridge and say things like "what a waste of money", that was not my point, but at the same time I dont understand the need for such a device....not for what we do....

Any way my opinion is mine, yours is yours, in the end thats all there is

Steve...

PS wow this has gotten way out of proportion...I feel there are more underlieing things here, the problem being me....It has been a long winter, and time that we met face to face.....To be truethfull I for one am worried at this point... 

Andy Berglund



03/31/2009 11:52 PM Alert 
Agreed Steven. I think as long as we're getting out there and enjoying the world. Just wait until you have a chance to see an Engel in action...

A

I am loving the Gilmore Girls-Scott Williams
TooRisky



04/01/2009 11:22 PM Alert 

Ok thats it... Time for the gloves to hit the ground, lets go, me against the lot of you ...cmon ya chickens....ROFL....ahhh Just kidding...Funny how grown men can take a silly subject like this and get into a heated arguement....Its good at one point that we all have hard fast beliefs, will to argue or validate our own personal position. At the same time I give Kudos to each of you in this debate for not getting personal, I love a good debate, rules intact, and let the ideas fly with out personal attack, I bow to each contender...Well done...

I do so look forward to fireside chats...So many points to debate, keep on your toes Ivey league, the riff raff has infiltrated and can stand toe to toe in any heated debate...English rules do apply...and spelling does not count....(not my strong point)

Looking forward to meeting you all....

Steve

PS Craig, explain the motivation of cutting this off into its own discussion, just dose not make sense other than stirring the pot.....

Craig Miller
Title Sponsor


04/01/2009 11:33 PM Alert 
The information in this split thread is off-topic from Benny's original question.

My Overland Adventure Blog
Nate Skate



04/02/2009 8:15 AM Alert 
I'm sorely tempted by the new ARB fridge at that price, but I'm putting off buying a fridge because of the weight, size, and the possibility of draining the battery when out solo. I've also noticed that even in really remote places like the Alvord Desert or the Ruby Mountains it's hard to not drive by a minimart in 3-4 days of traveling, which a good cooler like the Coleman Extremes, or better yet, a Yeti, my next purchase, can handle with ease. Besides, having a meal of canned peaches and deviled ham on crackers after the ice runs out makes one feel macho.
Grant Mossman
Member Sponsor


04/02/2009 8:27 AM Alert 
Nate- I'm with you. I can go two weeks on PBJ sandwiches and dr pepper
Grrr!

Everett, Reno, Astoria, BedStuy, Greenpoint, Bayfield, Brazos, Albuquerque
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Page 1 of 3123 > >>

Forums > Skills & Gear > Adventure Gear > To fridge or not to fridge



ActiveForums 3.6
Copyright (C) 2010 Northwest Overland Society, LLC   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement