LoginRegister Search
Subject: cooking gear review: Cabela's "pre-seasoned" Dutch Ovens

You are not authorized to post a reply.   
AuthorMessages
Ryan McDonald



11/25/2009 11:06 PM Alert 

I had some Cabela's Bucks saved up from this summer and purchased two 24" pre-seasoned dutch ovens. As a dutch oven enthusiast and Scout Master I was skeptical at the notion of trusting a company to adequately season my dutch oven. But I at least placed my trust in the return policy and took the set home along with a set of the padded zipper totes.

I cooked two dishes: Corn chowder and Bannana-nut cake.

The ovens heated up very quickly and seem to distribute the heat very well. The oven rim has a thermometer port from which I assessed the "pre-heating" time to 350 degrees F in less than 10 minutes with 20 briquetes bottom, and 12 on top. The lids have a deep rim that keeps the coals and resulting ash from falling off as you remove and replace per recipes and anxious curiousity. I have a custom made lid lifter.

After my family and neighbors devoured the meal, clean-up was surprisingly enjoyable with minimal scraping and zero scrubbing. Moist paper towels and then a damp shop-towel returned them to their original finish. I smeared a tablespoon of canola oil inside shortly before stowing per my own superstitions.

Overall a very very nice piece of camp/home cookware.

Strengths: Excellent pre-seasoning. Good head conduction and distribution, even with poor quality briquettes. Deep lids for coal and ash retention. Heavy guage wire handle does not heat up.

Weaknesses: I found the legs a tad too short. This promises to limit airflow and thus suffocate my briquettes. Either a riser, shallow pit or frequent attention will remedy this issue. Heavy, bulky piece of equipment.

Suggestions: be certain to protect the pot and your other gear by purchasing the zipper-padded cases. These keep things clean and allow you to stow utensils inside the dutch oven during transport.

I hope this review is helpful. I would love to hear any additional insight. Cheers!


Going to sleep is the easy part...
Todd Eliason
Title Sponsor


11/29/2009 12:18 AM Alert 
I want to travel (and eat) with you Ryan!

93 LR Defender 110
05 Land Rover LR3
Tom Thomas



01/06/2010 7:56 AM Alert 
Ryan, thanks for the review. I've got several pieces of cast iron cookware that I love, one being my great grandmothers skillet.
Have you tried an aluminum dutch oven though? I'd like to hear input on those (trying to lighten my load, so to speak)
Ryan McDonald



01/18/2010 9:42 PM Alert 
Tom,

I have used aluminum dutch ovens while a raft guide; I believe the weight savings is not worth the lack in heat retention. Cast aluminum griddle works well because you would want to fine-tune your heat for your hot-cakes, fish etc... but for sure use what you like, that way you get the best and most consistent results.

I would for sure hang onto that skillet! I learned last year that any dutch oven/skillet made pre 1974 (+/-?) is superior to the others because the sand used in the casting process was much much finer than that used today; I think it had something to do with industrial exposure to fine-particle sand...anyway, the result is a pan that has very small pores and thus better heat retention, complete curing and easier cleaning...nice.

Going to sleep is the easy part...
Craig Miller
Title Sponsor


03/13/2010 11:58 PM Alert 
Ryan,

You should post this in the "Blogs" section under Reviews so it doesn't get lost in the never ending chatter of the forums. Just copy/paste it, and it will work great.

Craig

My Overland Adventure Blog
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Forums > Skills & Gear > Cooking > cooking gear review: Cabela's "pre-seasoned" Dutch Ovens



ActiveForums 3.6
Copyright (C) 2010 Northwest Overland Society, LLC   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement